St. Petersburg Probate Litigation Lawyer
When disputes arise during the probate process, families often find themselves facing complex legal challenges that require experienced representation. At Drude Tomori Law, PA, our St. Petersburg probate litigation lawyer provides dedicated advocacy for clients navigating contested estates, will disputes, and other probate-related conflicts. Rachel Drude-Tomori combines over 15 years of legal experience with a collaborative approach to dispute resolution, while also serving as a zealous advocate in the courtroom when necessary.
Probate litigation can emerge from various circumstances, including questions about a will’s validity, disputes among beneficiaries, concerns about executor misconduct, or disagreements regarding asset distribution. Our St. Petersburg law firm understands the emotional and financial toll these disputes can take on families, which is why we work diligently to resolve conflicts efficiently while protecting our clients’ interests and rights under Florida law.
What Is Probate Litigation?
Probate litigation encompasses a broad range of disputes that arise during the probate process, which is the legal mechanism for settling a deceased person’s estate. These disputes can occur when beneficiaries, creditors, or other interested parties challenge the validity of the estate plan, the actions of a personal representative, or the distribution of assets. At Drude Tomori Law, we are experienced in handling the following types of probate litigation:
- Will Disputes: While challenging a will is one aspect of probate litigation, these cases are often part of broader conflicts over the estate.
- Trust Litigation: Issues such as breaches of fiduciary duty, unclear trust terms, or disagreements among beneficiaries frequently lead to legal disputes.
- Guardianship Disputes: Litigation may arise over the appointment of a legal guardian or the management of a ward’s assets and well-being.
- Estate Administration Conflicts: Personal representatives are tasked with critical responsibilities, and disputes can arise over allegations of mismanagement, theft, or failure to fulfill fiduciary duties.
- Creditor Claims: Probate often involves addressing claims against the estate. When creditors and beneficiaries disagree, litigation may be required to resolve the matter.
Understanding Probate Litigation in Florida
Probate litigation encompasses a wide range of legal disputes that can arise during the administration of a deceased person’s estate. In Florida, these cases are typically heard in the Pinellas County Probate Court, located at 315 Court Street in Clearwater. The probate process itself can be supervised or unsupervised by the court, which impacts the level of oversight and the potential for disputes to emerge during estate administration.
Common types of probate litigation include will contests, where parties challenge the validity of a testamentary document based on claims of lack of capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution. Beneficiary disputes often arise when family members disagree about asset distribution or believe they have been unfairly excluded from an estate. Executor and trustee disputes can occur when beneficiaries question the personal representative’s decisions or suspect breach of fiduciary duty.
Asset disputes frequently involve disagreements about the valuation, ownership, or distribution of specific properties or investments. In some cases, creditor claims may be contested if beneficiaries believe the claims are invalid or improperly presented. Trust disputes can also fall under probate litigation when they involve questions about trust administration, interpretation of trust terms, or removal of trustees.
The complexity of these cases often requires extensive knowledge of Florida probate law, estate planning principles, and litigation strategy. Our firm’s comprehensive understanding of both estate planning and probate administration provides a unique advantage in resolving disputes efficiently and effectively.
Common Causes of Probate Litigation
Probate disputes can arise for a variety of reasons, including disagreements over the interpretation of a will or trust, concerns about undue influence or fraud, and conflicts between beneficiaries and personal representatives. Some of the most common issues include:
- Undue Influence: Allegations that someone manipulated the deceased to alter their estate plan.
- Lack of Capacity: Claims that the deceased did not understand the decisions they were making due to diminished mental capacity.
- Improper Administration: Accusations that the estate is being mishandled or mismanaged.
Navigating these disputes requires a comprehensive understanding of Florida probate law and a commitment to resolving conflicts efficiently and effectively. At Drude Tomori Law, we bring this expertise to every probate litigation case we handle.
Why Choose Drude Tomori Law for Probate Litigation?
At Drude Tomori Law, we understand that probate litigation is not just a legal matter—it’s a deeply personal one. Our team is dedicated to protecting our clients’ rights, preserving family relationships when possible, and achieving the best possible outcomes in challenging situations. With a focus on understanding the unique aspects of each case, Rachel Drude-Tomori provides compassionate, client-focused representation that prioritizes your goals and concerns.
Our approach to probate litigation combines legal knowledge, creative problem-solving, and a deep commitment to our clients. Whether negotiating a resolution or litigating in court, we strive to make the process less stressful and more manageable.
Will Contests and Validity Challenges
Will contests represent one of the most common forms of probate litigation in St. Petersburg and throughout Florida. These disputes typically arise when family members or other interested parties believe a will does not accurately reflect the deceased person’s true intentions or was created under questionable circumstances. Florida law provides specific grounds for challenging a will’s validity, each requiring different types of evidence and legal strategies.
Lack of testamentary capacity is a frequent basis for will contests, particularly when the deceased was elderly or suffered from cognitive decline. In these cases, challengers must demonstrate that the testator did not understand the nature of their assets, the natural objects of their bounty, or the consequences of their testamentary decisions at the time of will execution. Medical records, witness testimony, and expert opinions often play crucial roles in these cases.
Undue influence claims arise when someone allegedly pressured or manipulated the testator into creating or modifying their will in a way that benefits the influencer. These cases often involve caregivers, family members in positions of trust, or individuals who isolated the deceased from other family members. Proving undue influence requires demonstrating that the influencer had the opportunity and disposition to exercise control and that the will reflects the influencer’s desires rather than the testator’s true intentions.
Fraud and forgery claims may arise when parties suspect that signatures were forged, documents were altered, or the testator was deceived about the contents of their will. Technical challenges to will execution focus on whether the document complies with Florida’s specific requirements for valid wills, including proper witnessing and notarization procedures.
Executor and Beneficiary Disputes
Conflicts between executors and beneficiaries can significantly complicate the probate process and may require court intervention to resolve. These disputes often center on the personal representative’s management of estate assets, their communication with beneficiaries, or their interpretation of the will’s terms. As experienced probate litigators, we help clients navigate these complex relationships and protect their rights throughout the administration process.
Breach of fiduciary duty claims can arise when beneficiaries believe the executor has failed to act in the estate’s best interests. This might include allegations of self-dealing, failure to preserve or properly manage assets, unauthorized distributions, or conflicts of interest. Executors have strict legal obligations under Florida law, and violations can result in personal liability, removal from their position, and potential damages.
Asset management disputes frequently occur in estates with significant business interests, real property, or investment portfolios. Beneficiaries may question the executor’s decisions about whether to sell assets, how to value properties, or investment strategies during the administration period. These cases often require expert testimony from appraisers, accountants, or business valuation specialists.
Communication failures can also lead to litigation when executors fail to provide required notices, accounting information, or updates about the estate’s progress. Florida law mandates specific reporting requirements, and beneficiaries have rights to information about the estate’s administration. Our firm helps both executors understand their obligations and beneficiaries enforce their rights to transparency and accountability.
St. Petersburg Probate Litigation FAQs
How long do I have to contest a will in Florida?
Florida law generally provides a three-month deadline to contest a will after receiving formal notice of probate administration. However, this timeline can vary depending on the specific circumstances of your case and the type of challenge being raised. It’s crucial to consult with an experienced probate litigation attorney as soon as possible if you believe you have grounds to contest a will.
What are the costs associated with probate litigation?
Probate litigation costs can vary significantly depending on the complexity of the case, the amount of discovery required, and whether the matter proceeds to trial. Costs may include attorney fees, expert witness fees, court costs, and deposition expenses. In some cases, attorney fees may be paid from the estate itself, particularly when the litigation benefits all beneficiaries or involves executor misconduct.
Can probate litigation be resolved without going to court?
Many probate disputes can be resolved through negotiation, mediation, or other alternative dispute resolution methods. Our firm takes a collaborative approach to dispute resolution and works to find efficient solutions that preserve family relationships when possible. However, we are prepared to litigate aggressively in court when settlement negotiations are unsuccessful.
What evidence do I need to challenge a will?
The evidence required depends on the specific grounds for your challenge. Will contests based on lack of capacity may require medical records, witness testimony about the deceased’s mental state, and expert medical opinions. Undue influence cases often rely on evidence of the influencer’s relationship with the deceased, isolation from family, and suspicious circumstances surrounding will creation or modification.
Can an executor be removed during probate administration?
Yes, Florida law allows for the removal of personal representatives who breach their fiduciary duties, become incapacitated, or are otherwise unable to fulfill their responsibilities. The court may remove an executor for reasons including self-dealing, failure to properly account for estate assets, conflicts of interest, or failure to follow the will’s terms or court orders.
How does probate litigation affect estate distribution?
Probate litigation typically delays the final distribution of estate assets until the dispute is resolved. During litigation, the court may issue orders preserving estate assets, limiting the executor’s authority, or requiring court approval for certain actions. The outcome of litigation can significantly impact how assets are ultimately distributed among beneficiaries.
What happens if a will is successfully contested?
If a will contest is successful, the contested will may be declared invalid in whole or in part. If the entire will is invalidated, the estate may be distributed according to a previous valid will or Florida’s intestacy laws if no other valid will exists. Partial invalidation might affect only specific provisions while leaving the remainder of the will intact.
Serving Throughout St. Petersburg
- Downtown St. Petersburg
- Old Northeast
- Snell Isle
- Historic Kenwood
- Crescent Lake
- Disston Heights
- Shore Acres
- Bahama Shores
- Lakewood Estates
- Azalea
Contact a St. Petersburg Probate Litigation Attorney Today
If you are facing a probate dispute or believe you have grounds to contest a will, don’t delay in seeking experienced legal representation. The dedicated probate litigation attorney at Drude Tomori Law, PA, provides skilled advocacy and personalized attention to clients throughout the Greater Tampa Bay Area. Rachel Drude-Tomori’s extensive experience in both estate planning and probate litigation provides unique insights into resolving complex family disputes while protecting your interests and rights. Contact our St. Petersburg office today to discuss your case and learn how we can help you navigate the probate litigation process with confidence and peace of mind.
